Short review: this book was not good.
The premise sounded somewhat interesting: a girl is accused of killing her best friend over a guy while studying abroad in Italy, but has no memory of the trip. Very Amanda Knox.
The writing was clumsy, the plot was boring and made no sense, the characters were flat. I finished it mostly because I was bored. Jill, the main character struggles with her amnesia, saying:
“I concentrated, trying to recall more, but it was like my brain was constipated.”
For real? You couldn’t think of any better way to phrase this?
Her characters don’t talk like real teenagers, it’s more like a grandma’s idea of how teenagers speak. There are several segments featuring online chats where characters say “Gurl”, “I M here 4 u” and “bee-otch”. Come on, now. This sounds like how people wrote emails in the dawn of the internet, when it was still called “the web” and we were all drowning in AOL free trial CDs.
This book was a nice try that fell flat.